Tuesday, May 02, 2006

Da Vinci and Crocodile Dundee

I've read a lot material on the Da Vinci Code, but I finally saw a program that I thought was the best. It reminded me of Crocodile Dundee. One of my favorite parts in the movie Crocodile Dundee (maybe everybody's favorite part) is when a street tough pulls a knife on Mick and his girlfriend and demands their money. Mick laughs and says, "That's not a knife." And then he pulls out his knife, which is enormous, and he says, "That's a knife." He then proceeds to slash the punk's jacket. What a great movie moment.

I read the Da Vinci Code two years ago and thought it was a pretty good read, aside from the obvious slams at the church. Then my wife and I went to Paris and while we were at the Louvre I thought it would be fun to videotape all the paintings Dan Brown mentioned in his book. While filming the first painting I could see how far-fetched his ideas were. There was no basis for his interpretation at all (in my opinion). I turned off the video camera. I had better things to film.

Two years later I'm amazed at how much press this book, and now the movie, is getting. One article I read was sort of a post-modern, story we find outselves in, it's all the Church's own fault because we aren't missional, bla bla bla kind of article. Some articles have been along the line of an overwrought Italian mother hysterically asking, "How could you do this?" A couple of articles in Christianity Today were pretty good.

MKH and I were watching the Discovery channel the other day and a program came on that totally destroyed Dan Brown and his "research." First they brought up one of the numerous conspiracies mentioned in his book and then they investigated it and proved it false, or a hoax, a lie, or pure fabrication. Then because Dan Brown wouldn't grant them an interview they kept showing a tape of him from another interview saying that everything in the book is fact. Then they would go on to debunk the next "fact" from his book.

That's not a knife (fact) Dan Brown, THIS is a KNIFE (FACT). It was just the best thing I'd seen for awhile.

I was a little disturbed by the "post modern" sounding article I read. Is there ever a time when someone or something is an enemy? We do have an enemy you know. Jesus called people white-washed tombs. He called his friend Peter "satan." Jesus turned over tables and called people a "brood of vipers." Paul said that he wished the Judaizers would just go "cut themselves off." There are those who present themselves to be wise, in the know, religious, pious who are false prophets and deceivers. Some people are not honest seekers after the truth. I wonder if Christians realize what kind of fight we're in at times. Sometimes you can't just drink a cup of coffee and dialogue with the enemy. Goddess worship will not help anyone. Some deceivers will lead people astray, maybe not you or me, but it will happen.

Even though it wasn't a "Christian" show I'm glad the Discovery channel aired a program that had the guts to say, "THIS is a KNIFE" and sliced up some falsehoods.

7 Comments:

At 8:06 AM, Blogger Lowery said...

Hey. It's Brian Lowery. I'm a good friend of Jon's and I think your family is pretty amazing. I stop by your blog every once and awhile and enjoy your stuff. I noticed your reflections on Da Vinci and enjoyed them and was challenged by them. I couldn't help but wonder if the "postmodernish" article you had read was the one I put out on Relevant (I know you frequent Toadie's blog which had a link to it). Indeed, it may not be the article you read and I'm drawing silly conclusions. If it is, I apologize that it was a "blah, blah, blah" read for you. I certainly didn't intend for it to be, but I think your points are all very valid and I can see where you are coming from quite clearly and that perhaps I was one big turn off. For sure, some folks did not like my thoughts!

I agree whole-heartedly that we have an enemy and are often distracted by what we perceive our enemies to be. At times we forget we have an enemy. Then at times, I think we give our enemies too much press and thus more ammunition. That's an ongoing thing I struggle with in my own thought world. Your thoughts on this were so very good. Thanks for the insights. I'm still mulling them over as I move forward in my own response to all of this and such.

I will say, however, that for me personally this Da Vinci phenomenon is a telling one (as I wrote in the article) and I'm desperately trying to learn from it and to help my faith community learn from it - and not just in ways where we can defend ourselves or try and figure out issues of enemy identity. I do in fact want to learn how this can further our development as a missional people. I think it's worthy of some real pause and not just to study the latest by Josh McDowell. The truth is, these are telling times concerning the church and the missional aspect or lack therof. I'm not sure we should be quick to dismiss what this moment in time tells us. It's not just an opportunity to discredit some heresy. It's an opportunity to revisit mission and that which sets our hearts racing. Brown's work is truly laughable to me. I am going to engage in "dealing with it" from a teaching standpoint. But I'm also going to encourage our faith community to return to being a missional people and maybe just maybe - though many more challenges will come along - we can avoid this huge of a trap and this odd need to have packages and programs and such. The fact that 46 million people have been enraptured by the work of Dan Brown tells me that perhaps they are seeking more than we give them credit for. Perhaps they are wanting to see and hear more and not just on the other side of some pop culture explosion. In my original draft, I wrote that conspiracy theories and even laughable ones exist in the vacuum of a satisfying narrative. It's true with JFK. It's true with Christ. To me, to some degree, we are often not allowing a mission to have hold of us. We are waiting...pushing for people to come to us...reacting to the next big opportunity. I sometimes do thank God for the Da Vinci Code if for one reason - we seem a little more charged than usual to deal with our rich history and our story with little to no shame. We seem to like a mission and lots of folks are on one now with the release of the book and the film. I just find it all to be a troubling pill to swallow because we had a mission before the book and its corresponding movie came out.

I think the "missional benefits" of this could be huge and not just the intellectual benefits. I do fear the former is prone to get lost in favor of the latter. We may "take Brown down" and may have helped a lot of people learn some things on the other side of this. But what did we learn as we move forward? What does this tell us? I've learned a lot about the Judas documents and Gnostic histories and such. That's been good. But I've also learned a lot about myself and my own paralysis in missional living and frankly, that's been better.

I really do appreciate your thoughts. I agree with them 100%. I would just say maybe weigh the missional lessons that can be learned in this alongside of the other things. I find all of this to be of good help to us all as we move forward in this mission.

Anyway, my friend, I hope things are going quite well in your neck of the woods and hey - you've got another beautiful little grandchild coming here in just a bit. That's pretty wonderful.

Talk to you soon.

 
At 8:14 PM, Blogger TWH said...

Brian, I read your article in RELEVANT. It is a very well written article. I didn't have you in mind when I wrote my blog although I can see why you might have thought I did. Your comments are very serious, my blog is really more just for fun although occasionally I do write about things that I care very much about.

I try not to be reactionary toward people I know in my blogs, just impersonal entities. Besides my son wouldn't like it if I criticized one of his friends.

Having said that and after reading your article again I will argue with you a bit in a friendly way.

You might be right about the Da Vinci Code "challenging the evangelical world in the area we seem to covet the most--the intellectual." Or maybe that's true for your generation as opposed to my generation. But my own personal opinion is that the Da Vinci Code is so popular because of three reasons. 1. People love a conspiracy especially when it involves the Catholic Church, the Masons and other groups that have some mystery attached to them. 2. People love to topple authority figures. 3. Most people in my generation know what the Bible and Christians are saying, they just don't like how being a Christian would cramp their lifestyle. Some famous atheist that JDH has quoted to me said that he doesn't want to believe that God created..."he doesn't want the universe to be that way." Another former atheist (I'd look these quotes up if I was in my office) said something about not wanting to believe because he wanted to keep the sin that he had in his life. Some non-believers would like to reinvent religion more to their liking and if the Gospel of Judas, or the Da Vinci Code, or some other far out spurious writing surfaces that could help them justify their life apart from God then that's just what they want.

I think in your generation, a lot of people haven't heard the gospel. No one took them to Sunday School. I often run into people in your generation and just a little bit older who tell me that their only exposure to the church was a VBS they attended once or twice when they were little. They don't own a Bible. Imagine that, Indianapolis, the land of megachurches and people don't even have a Bible.

I think you might be giving "a proactive Dan Brown" too much credit when you say he gave the world a story to flock to in the absence of a clear, meaningful, provocative, incarnate story about Christ and Christian history."

You might be right but at least for me, when I'm on vacation I like to read a good page turner and the Da Vinci Code was it until the next Grisham novel or Harry Potter book came out. Brown can tell a story and he got really lucky with this one. It's all become news because people know so little about church history. On top of that Brown keeps claiming that it's all fact. He reminds me of an old time "All Star Wrestler" claiming that everything in wrestling is for real. Maybe that's his strategy. It worked for wrestling.

I'm not into recommending movies, even if it's Aslan. I don't want to be a publicist for anyone, or to market the church, for anything. I made some copies of some good articles and the Gospel of Judas available for people who wanted it, but I won't be preaching about "Who is Mary Magdalene and was Jesus married to her?" Others are, and maybe they're right to do so. That's not for me.

Thanks for reading and commenting on my blog. If some folks didn't like your article, don't let that discourage you. You are a gifted writer--I'm sure you know that.

 
At 10:53 AM, Blogger Lowery said...

Awesome points all around. One that you've really helped me see in your response is that there are for sure generational layers to this phenomena and thus even some generational responses. Great, great point about your generation loving a good conspiracy and more precisely, your generation's tending to want to see authority brought low. That is a really great insight. Not one I had thought of. Thanks for shating that.

I think we both have meaningful points. I'm not saying that to pat myself on the back - more so, to pat your caution to me on the back. I need that. I am finding myself needing to be open to all angles and take the good and insightful from whatever I can. I did in the article stress the need to respond and the dangers inherent in being lazy in our defense. I just want us all to be cautious about stressing defense so much that we ignore the lesson that can be learned to be proactive.

You may be right indeed - I may be giving Brown a lot more credit than is due. At the same time, I have so many people who have been believers for years who have said to me, "I never knew that. That was interesting. How come we never talk about some of this history?" And I wonder, "What have we been missing in our teaching and instruction?" Add to that - how can we live more obviously to encourage dialogue now and not later on the other end of a new "opportunity." To me, the Da Vinci Code phenomena is no more greater an opportunity than the day before it came out was. It may have just pushed the door open a little more than usual.

Thank you so very, very much for the interaction on this. It has helped me immensely, my friend.

And by the way, even if you had been picking on me, it would be fine. Jon picks on me every time he and I hang out. I'm used to it. :)

 
At 4:43 PM, Blogger Tyler said...

okay i'm happy you guys are having such a wonderful dialogue here, but I'd like to draw your attention to the first paragraph of the the third comment. In the last sentence Brian writes:

"Thanks for shating that."

I almost spit coke all over my computer. :)

I wish i could contribute more, but i haven't read the book, seen any tv specials or read any articles.

 
At 6:44 AM, Blogger Lowery said...

Yep. I saw that after I posted it Tyler. I must confess I laughed, too. I think I can try and edit it if I like, but the levity of it makes me say, "Let it stand for all the world to see." When I read it aloud, I laugh and laugh. "Thanks for shating that."

 
At 12:39 PM, Blogger TWH said...

Now all we need is for Jonathan and Adam to weigh in on this and then it will seem like a holiday mealtime discussion around the table. If you're reading, "shat" a little.

 
At 5:54 PM, Blogger Adam said...

I can't say much about the book cause I haven't read much or watched much. Just seemed like a waste of time. My defence then, "Na that dude is lying and it isn't all fact" Just watch shows debunking his stuff.

I do know people want to watch the church burn. I mean this was a great conversation.

Ann:I don't want to be a Christian
Me: Why not
Ann:Cause I like to say F***
Me:ooookkkkk......
Ann:I think the church is stupid and needs to burn itself down cause it is doing more harm than good.
Me:Oh man I would love to talk to you some more about that but my flight is coming in.

She is probably worshiping Dan Brown and starting her own cult or something

 

Post a Comment

<< Home